As Cardinal Burke has stated all along, AL is the pope expressing an opinion, and because that opinion is heterodox, it does NOT represent an act of the Magisterium. I'll take his opinion over that of a piano teacher like Walford any day.
Brother Al, How can you be a member of this site and not realize this is exactly what is going on? No one on either side of the argument is denying this is happening. Some people just feel this is okay and some don't. That is what the discussion is about. Not whether it is happening or not. My mouth hit the floor when I saw you wrote this.
There's no more room for this credulous nonsense among thinking Catholics. It makes us look like gullible fools in the minds of allies and enemies alike.
Was France not called "Daughter of the Church" not so long ago? I'm thinking that we should spend a lot less time worrying about The Vatican Falling and who goes to the "Communion Rail" and a lot more time worrying about Old Christendom in your Country, State or Community! The forces at work in the below have already targeted Christians/Jews and will be burning Churches/Synagogues before year's end, Methinks? Since we can't call these Islamic "Youths" the Terrorist Criminals that they are thanks to Left Media/Political Parties and 50 Years of Political Correctness. I guess you can go back to worrying about that Communion Rail and St Peter's Square and pretend that year's end is ....................????? I'll "Dig-Up and paraphase poor old Sir John again: "Terrorism doth not prosper. What is the reason? For if it doth, none dare call it Terrorism!" .... you could just as well substitute: Criminality, godlessness,..................... After the Churches/Synagogues go up in flames, thanks to the Islamic & any Left Anarchist Group Ya can name! Your businesses and homes will be next. It has happened in every Human Upheaval ...... World War, Revolution, Religious Wars .... it will happen again .... & again till Scripture is fulfilled! "Cars torched as tensions flare in Paris suburb" http://www.reuters.com/article/us-france-police-violence-idUSKBN15M1NU GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
Pope Francis marks "day for life" with abortion lobby's language Pope Francis has marked the "day for life" in Italy by adopting the abortion lobby's euphemism "interruption of pregnancy" in place of language that accurately describes the killing of unborn children. Phrases such as "interruption of pregnancy" and "termination of pregnancy" are used by the abortion lobby - people who promote, or carry out, the killing of children - to deflect from the reality of abortion. The term "interruption of pregnancy" is particularly offensive as the life of the unborn child is not "interrupted" by abortion, but permanently ended - it can never be resumed. The use of such language by Pope Francis reflects a growing convergence of language, policies and ideas between the Vatican authorities and the international population control movement: Pope Francis has professed himself "gratified" by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals which call for "universal access to sexual and reproductive health" by 2030. These terms are used by United Nations agencies, international organisations and many national governments to promote universal access to abortion and contraception. The Vatican has hosted many of the population control movement's most influential figures, such as Professor Jeffrey Sachs, who has taken part in at least ten Vatican events during the current pontificate. Paul Ehrlich, who has called for forced abortion and mass sterilisation, will be a guest speaker at an event jointly hosted by the Pontifical Academy of Science and the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences later this month. The Pontifical Council for the Family has produced a sex education programme that contains obscene images. Dr Rick Fitzgibbons, a psychiatrist and adjunct professor of the Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, at the Catholic University of America, has worked with children who have been victims of clerical sex abuse and with priests who have carried out such abuse. After reviewing the PCF's programme Dr Fitzgibbons said "in my professional opinion, the most dangerous threat to Catholic youth that I have seen over the past 40 years is the Vatican’s new sexual education program, The Meeting Point: Course of Affective Sexual Education for Young People." He continued, "I was particularly shocked by the images contained in this new sex education program, some of which are clearly pornographic. My immediate professional reaction was that this obscene or pornographic approach abuses youth psychologically and spiritually." Conservative estimates indicate that over one billion unborn human lives have been lost since the legalisation of abortion across most of the world in the twentieth century. These killings exceed the number of people killed in all the wars throughout all of recorded human history, where estimates of deaths range from 150 million to 1 billion. Yet Pope Francis, while he has made some brief references to abortion in homilies or speeches, has done nothing of any substance to address this mass killing. The documents of the two synods on the family, which were all approved by the pope prior to publication, either didn't mention the issue at all, or only made brief passing reference to abortion – which has, throughout the world, targeted for mass destruction the most vulnerable member of the family, the unborn child, and which has caused untold damage to the surviving members of the families concerned. The Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, purportedly about helping families in the modern world, but actually serving to undermine Catholic teaching on the nature of the moral law, contains only two passing references to abortion (in paragraphs 42 and 179), neither of which are condemnation of the practice as an evil per se. To give so little space, in a document on the family, to a crime which targets the most vulnerable members of the family in the sanctuary of their mothers' wombs, reflects a shocking detachment from the fate of unborn children. Pope Francis's comfortable co-existence with the "culture of death" was clearly displayed when he referred to abortionist Emma Bonino, who has been one of Italy's leading abortion advocates for decades, as a "forgotten great". It can also be seen in his September 2013 interview with Antonio Spadaro in which he stated that "We cannot insist only on issues related to abortion, gay marriage and the use of contraceptive methods." The problem is that, far from speaking too much about abortion, the Catholic hierarchy has been, with a few honourable exceptions, largely silent over the last fifty years in the face of the greatest mass killing of human beings in history. Today Voice of the Family would like to respectfully remind the Holy Father, and the wider Church, of the reality of what abortion methods really involve. In the following videos, produced by LiveAction, former abortionist Anthony Levantino explains what really happens during abortion procedures. Please view the videos at the Voice of Family website.
Just some food for thought regarding using our consciences as justification to receive communion while in a state of serious sin. Apparently this is as old as it comes and nothing new: Letter of St Jerome to Eustochium 384 A.D. "13. I cannot bring myself to speak of the many virgins who daily fall and are lost to the bosom of the church, their mother: stars over which the proud foe sets up his throne, Isaiah 14:13 and rocks hollowed by the serpent that he may dwell in their fissures. You may see many women widows before wedded, who try to conceal their miserable fall by a lying garb. Unless they are betrayed by swelling wombs or by the crying of their infants, they walk abroad with tripping feet and heads in the air. Some go so far as to take potions, that they may insure barrenness, and thus barreness, and thus murder human beings almost before their conception. Some, when they find themselves with child through their sin, use drugs to procure abortion, and when (as often happens) they die with their offspring, they enter the lower world laden with the guilt not only of adultery against Christ but also of suicide and child murder. Yet it is these who say: 'Unto the pure all things are pure;' Titus 1:15 my conscience is sufficient guide for me. A pure heart is what God looks for. Why should I abstain from meats which God has created to be received with thanksgiving?1 Timothy 4:3 And when they wish to appear agreeable and entertaining they first drench themselves with wine, and then joining the grossest profanity to intoxication, they say Far be it from me to abstain from the blood of Christ." http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/3001022.htm
Thank you for this, MS7. Mr Walford has now become another 'hate' figure on the forum but he writes well and addresses the issues clearly and fairly.
Typical of a Liberal - quick to use the 'hate' adjective when it suits the agenda. Mr Walford had a not so proud History on this forum and that is being kind.
Oh come on, garabandal. I put the word in inverted commas...... Let me re-phrase for sensitive souls. Mr Walford has now become another figure who is dismissed out of hand on the forum but he writes well and addresses the issues clearly and fairly. What happened with his involvement on the forum was not a very good example of the forum as a 'listening' forum.
Garabandal, I know it takes time to construct a response to an article, but you took the easy way out with an ad hominem attack. Safe in the Hearts of Jesus and Mary!
Looks like ad hominem attacks are contagious. I only bring it up because both you and Garabandal are much more persuasive when you use your brains. Safe in the Hearts of Jesus and Mary!
You are correct. It came highly recommended. I started reading then realised who the author was --- Given his attitude towards me and others on this forum -- I regret nothing! But I forgive him
What if we’ve been wrong about ‘Amoris’ all along? Father Matthew Schneider February 6, 2017 Pope Francis greets newly married couples during his general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican in this Sept. 30, 2015, file photo. (Credit: CNS photo/L'Osservatore Romano.) There’s a significant difference between those who understand Church teaching and still choose to engage in sexual relations in a second marriage, and those who fail to live the Church’s teaching either from ignorance or weakness. 'Amoris Laetitia' seems directed to the latter, not the former. Ever since it came out in April 2016, there’s been an avalanche of debate in Catholic circles about Amoris Laetitia, Pope Francis’s document on the family. At least in English, both sides seem to agree that it permits Communion for the divorced and civilly remarried who continue relations in some circumstances, and the dispute is over whether that’s a good or bad thing. Yet if you read Amoris as papal documents are supposed to be read, meaning absorbing the full text in the context of Catholic tradition, the whole premise of the debate may be flawed - that is, Pope Francis may not have opened to door to Communion after all. Pope Benedict XVI used the phrase “hermeneutic of continuity” to refer to reading as a whole and within tradition, and Cardinal Gerhard Müller, the Vatican’s top doctrinal official, has said that’s the only way to read Amoris. That’s what I will attempt here. Before we dive in, there’s a crucial distinction to make: There’s a significant difference between those who understand Church teaching and still choose to engage in sexual relations in a second marriage, and those who fail to live the Church’s teaching either from ignorance or weakness. Pope Francis seems to make this distinction more clearly than previous Church teaching. Here’s the bottom line: Contrary to popular opinion, the text of Amoris Laetita does not allow those flagrantly or intentionally having marital-like relations in a “second marriage” to receive absolution or Communion. However, Francis emphasizes mercy for those who are either ignorant, or who intend to abstain from sexual relations but occasionally fail. Francis’s emphasis on mercy seems to come from a stronger emphasis on the wound of original sin in his anthropology. I will now demonstrate that this is the meaning of Amoris Laetitia using four groups of texts. Amoris Laetitia texts First, Francis makes it clear he does not intend to make new rules. Paragraph 300 says, “Neither the Synod nor this document could be expected to provide a new set of general rules, canonical in nature and applicable in all cases.” Even when talking about gradually showing couples the reality of their sin, Francis notes, “Discernment can never prescind from the Gospel demands as proposed by the Church.” Thus, no matter what he says about discernment later, he has set up the already existing teaching of the Church as a fence around what can be discerned. Discernment is a process of deciding spiritually what to do - like if you should pray the rosary or liturgy of the hours daily - but a basic pre-existing condition for proper discernment is you can’t choose something outside of Church teaching. Church teaching has been very clear that sacramental absolution, and thus Eucharistic Communion cannot be given to those who intend to commit more mortal sins. We usually assume a person coming to confession is not obstinate in wanting to commit more mortal sins, but if a priest knows otherwise, absolution should be denied. This is distinct from weakness. In confession, a priest can absolve a man for drunkenness, even if they both know he’ll likely fall again; but he can’t absolve him if he says he wants to get drunk again this weekend. This section of Amoris Laetitia refers to the specific sin of having sex with someone who is your legal spouse but not your legitimate spouse. The pope even reiterates this in 307: “In no way must the Church desist from proposing the full ideal of marriage, God’s plan in all its grandeur.” From these texts, it seems clear that those who live in open disobedience to the command of chastity for divorced and civilly remarried couples, as presented in St. John Paul II’s 1981 document Familiaris Consortio, cannot be admitted to absolution or Communion. Second, he points out the difference between failing or ignorance, and flaunting sin. In 297, Francis says “If someone flaunts an objective sin as if it were part of the Christian ideal, or wants to impose something other than what the Church teaches … this is a case of something which separates from the community.” An “objective sin” is a sin insofar as can be seen from external acts, ignoring things like knowledge of the sin or degree of free will, and in this context indicates that nobody can claim sleeping with someone other than your legitimate spouse is moral. “Separation from the community” refers to separation from the Church, and thus from Communion. When he talks about integrating the divorced and civilly remarried into the Church in 299, the pope says it must be “While avoiding any occasion of scandal.” Since “scandal” refers to those acts which may induce someone else to sin, it must mean that some forms of integration of some divorced and remarried couples are sinful as otherwise there would be no danger of scandal. This shows some couples - those who try to live Church teaching - can be reintegrated, while others - those who intentionally do not follow Church teachings - can only be integrated partially (and not including Communion). Third, he notes the responsibility for sin varies between the weak and those flaunting disobedience of Familiaris Consortio. In 302 he notes, “While upholding a general rule, it is necessary to recognize that responsibility with respect to certain actions and decisions is not the same in all cases.” Those who intend to continue sexual relations in opposition to existing Church teaching, and those who fall into it in a moment of weakness or are unaware of the Church’s teaching, definitely have differing responsibility for their acts. In 304 he suggests that we discern in the concrete circumstances of an individual’s life, not just the objective actions’ correspondence to a general rule. A big focus of a concrete life situation is whether someone knows Church teaching and is trying to live it out or not. Fourth and finally, he talks about mercy in the confessional towards those who are attempting to live the Church’s teaching as best they know it. He notes in 311, “Mercy does not exclude justice and truth, but first and foremost we have to say that mercy is the fullness of justice and the most radiant manifestation of God’s truth.” Thus, mercy in a confessional cannot be separate from the truth and justice which includes all previous Church teaching. The famous footnote 351 of Amoris Laetitia must be interpreted in this broader context. When footnote 351 says, “In certain cases, [help for those not fully living the Church’s objective teaching regarding marriage] can include the help of the sacraments,” it logically refers to those who are attempting to live previously established Church teaching as best they understand it - this is precisely the text preceding the footnote. This would apply both to those who don’t understand Church teaching on “second marriages,” and those who fail because of human weakness. From what has been said above and following the tradition of the Church, it seems clear that the “certain cases” refers to the ignorant and weak, and not to those intentionally sleeping with someone who is not their legitimate spouse. continued....
continued.... Beyond the texts already quoted, if we read within the tradition, ambiguity should be read according to what tradition says not in opposition to it. If a pope wants to change an existing pastoral practice, the weight of tradition would require him to state it clearly, not imply it through an ambiguous reading of a footnote. This is not a novel interpretation but has been around since day one, and is the one that makes most sense in the context of the previous teaching. I gave it on the day it was released and in a study guide a few weeks later, but had not done a complete explanation and analysis before. But the following objection might be in some of your minds: Paragraph 301 of Amoris says that not all those in irregular situations “are living in a state of mortal sin and are deprived of sanctifying grace.” This leads us to recognize the distinction between objective acts and subjective culpability. The Church has always taught that a mortal sin, depriving the person of sanctifying grace, requires grave matter, knowledge of the sin, and sufficient freedom. Many people in irregular situations either don’t realize the irregularity, or fail through habit but don’t fully choose sexual relations (in the sense they didn’t seek relations but consented against their firm disposition to avoid relations in a moment of weakness) - these people do not commit a mortal sin, and thus perfectly fulfill what Francis refers to. Granted, I can see slight variations in emphasis when reading Amoris Laetitia. However, when read as a whole and within tradition, I do not believe that giving Communion to anyone in a “second marriage” who wants it can or should be read into the document, since it is not in the text and contradicts statements elsewhere in the text. I admit the language could have been clearer, but implying some change of doctrine due to lack of clarity seems a bit of a stretch. The spirit of a document cannot contradict its direct words. The direct words of Amoris Laetitia indicate there is no change in Church teaching, but a slight change in emphasis towards mercy for those who are either ignorant or attempting to live Church teaching but sometimes failing. https://cruxnow.com/commentary/2017/02/06/weve-wrong-amoris-along/
If marriage councling from priests has failed the married couple and they are clueless of what they entered into from God's teaching on aduterly (marriage and divorce) then why hasn't Pope Francis dealt with the root of the problem with his priests with an immediate new course? Why instead is he suggesting that the root of the problem [bad formation] can allow for a second bad bad decision [adultery] as the answer. The answer seems simple. Pope Francis has chosen false compassion in allowing for adulterous situations in lieu of correcting the root of the problem which is bad pastoral marriage formation. One could then ask another question. Can all the 10 commandments receive this same gift from a pope without changing one's sinful state in life? If a person has enjoyed sodomy or fornication can one continue doing this with the same false compassion for one's choices?
https://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2017/02/peter-says-no 17 Perhaps the greatest Anglican intellect of the late twentieth century, Henry Chadwick, described Blessed John Henry Cardinal Newman as “a formidable controversialist, as supreme a master of irony and satire as any in our literature.” There can be little doubt that Newman's skills both dazzled his followers and admirers, and infuriated those whose own ecclesial comfort required them to evade his conclusions. In the febrile aftermath of the “Papal Aggression,” the restoration of the English Catholic hierarchy in 1851, Julius Hare, Archdeacon of Chichester, read a Charge to the clergy of his archdeaconry, in which he unloaded his wrath on “Dr. Newman's Circaean talent for metamorphosing historical facts.” Newman has employed a large portion of his time and of his ingenuity in the twofold process of transmuting fable into history and history into fable, until he seems to have almost lost the perception that there is any real, abiding distinction between them, and to fancy that they become one or the other at the touch of a sophist’s wand. In our own day, as controversy swirls around the Bishop of Rome, we have much to learn from one particular touch of Newman’s “wand”—his account of what the pope can and cannot do. In the Apologia pro Vita Sua of 1864, Newman takes up a criticism leveled against Catholicism—namely, that it is intransigent. Rather than denying this charge, he accepts and strengthens it, then characteristically turns it against the Church’s critics: It is one of the reproaches urged against the Church of Rome, that it has originated nothing, and has only served as a sort of remora or break in the development of doctrine. And it is an objection which I embrace as a truth; for such I conceive to be the main purpose of its extraordinary gift. Newman denied that Rome was the site of innovation. He saw that “the Church of Rome possessed no great mind in the whole period of persecution,” nor in the centuries that followed. “For a long while, it has not a single doctor to show: St Leo, its first, is the teacher of one point of doctrine.” Just as Peter was not the dazzling originator of new teaching, his successors have more often served as a brake on innovation than as its impetus. Of course, theological creativity is currently much prized, not least by the pope. It appears to offer a way to break log-jams such as that involved in the ecclesial and sacramental status of those who have “remarried” after a divorce. Early in his pontificate, Pope Francis discovered that “one of my Cardinals” had written a fine book on mercy. As we say, he picked it up and ran with it. Before three years had passed, Amoris laetitia was bearing the fruits of the papal thinking. It is relevant to the thesis I am examining to point out the extreme length of this apostolic exhortation, as well as the immense volume of words that emerges almost daily from the Domus Sanctae Marthae. Papal prolixity, a malady both acute and chronic, combined with assertions (however ingenious) that non-x has “developed” into x, and has managed to do so in a less than three decades, can hardly be what Newman dreamed of when he praised the Roman Church for “serving as a sort of remora.” The current attitude stems from the kind of false ultramontanism that Newman feared. As the possibility became clear that the First Vatican Council would define the infallibility of the Roman Pontiff, Newman argued, in a famous letter to his bishop William Ullathorne, for the essentially negative nature of the Church's magisterium: When we are all at rest, and have no doubts, and at least practically, not to say doctrinally, hold the Holy Father to be infallible, suddenly there is thunder in the clear sky, and we are told to prepare for something, we know not what, to try our faith, we know not how. No impending danger is to be averted, but a great difficulty is to be created. Is this a proper work for an Ecumenical Council? … What have we done to be treated as the faithful never were treated before? When has the definition of doctrine de fide been a luxury of devotion, and not a stern painful necessity? Newman believed that the power to impose belief de fide is a weapon in the Church's armory to be used negatively, as “a stern painful necessity,” when an error has arisen or an “impending danger is to be averted.” He goes so far as to imply that magisterial intervention is “improper” except when there is an error to be condemned or averted. In other words, the Church behaves most properly when she resists innovation by saying (with St Paul at Galatians 1:8-9) anathema sit. Newman had the best of historical grounds for his belief that the Roman and conciliar magisterium functions as an obstacle to innovation. When the Anglican patristic scholar and Church historian Trevor Jalland concluded his Bampton Lectures at Oxford in 1942 (published in 1944 as The Church and the Papacy: A Historical Study), he spoke of the Roman Church as having “in its long and remarkable history a supernatural grandeur which no mere secular institution has ever attained in equal measure,” and went on to refer to “its strange, almost mystical, faithfulness to type, its marked degree of changelessness, its steadfast clinging to tradition and to precedent.” He headed one of his chapters with a line from the Annales of the pre-Classical Roman poet Ennius—Moribus antiquis res stat Romana viresque—thus linking the Christian Roman faithfulness to Tradition with the pagan Roman appetite for venerable and normative antiquity. We may recall the work of the great Dutch philologist Christine Mohrmann, who demonstrated that the style and idiom of liturgical Latin, particularly of the Canon of the Mass, was consciously based upon the archaic cultic Latin of the earliest pagan Roman antiquity. In other words, “Roman” means “what is authentic because it is old.” This seems not quite to be the Rome of Papa Bergoglio and his God of Surprises. When, in the second century, something recognizable as Church History begins to emerge, we find the Roman Church already exercising a negative charism of the exclusion of error. The significant teachers of Christian antiquity were not popes, and the heretical teachers did not spread their innovative perceptions from the city at the center of the world. To quote another Anglican, Dom Gregory Dix: Con't