The Vatican Has Fallen

Discussion in 'Church Critique' started by padraig, Dec 31, 2016.

  1. Astrolabe

    Astrolabe New Member

    Martina of course your friend can go to confession!! How else is a penitent sinner supposed to receive absolution from God?! Confession is exactly what those who have sinned are supposed to do. Say if I murdered somebody, or committed adultery, or robbed a bank...and I was sorry. I should get to confession asap. I think you may have misunderstood Praetorian's message. It sounds to me like he/she was only asking you to clarify if your friend actually goes to confession or not.

    Sure, if people in a state of mortal sin were not allowed to go to confession, how are they supposed to cleanse themselves of that sin?

    I hope this helps, and I hope your friend finds peace, and a resolution to her problems in accordance with God's will. It's easy to see you care about her very much, and she is very blessed to have such a good friend as you, who is looking out for her well-being :)
     
    Clare A and josephite like this.
  2. Astrolabe

    Astrolabe New Member

    In relation to the Judas/Eucharist topic: I don't know much about it, but my own limited understanding is that the Last Supper was not actually the holy Eucharist, because Our Lord had not died yet. Of course when the priest carries out the communion rite at mass, the bread and wine are changed to the actual Body and Blood of Christ, because that part of the mass is the sacrifice of the Lamb all over again, as occurred on Good Friday.

    But seeing as the Lamb had not been sacrificed yet, at the Last Supper, was it not simply just bread and wine that Jesus and the apostles ate? Because Jesus ate and drank too, and why would He eat and drink of His own flesh and blood?

    I sincerely hope that my questions/thoughts here do not offend God - or anyone on the forum! I am not trying to be disrespectful in any way. I have total respect for the Eucharist, I just question whether the Last Supper was the Eucharist or not.

    Perhaps there's a definite answer to this, and if anyone knows, I would be really grateful to know. I hope my ignorance on the subject doesn't show me up, or make me seem disrespectful in any way.

    Thanks in advance for any input...
     
  3. padraig

    padraig Powers

    I believe the answer to this question lies in the Eucharistic Prayer, which is itself a tissue of Scriptures and expresses the Traditional Belief of the Church down the centuries in this regard:

    'While they were eating, Jesus took bread, said the blessing, broke it, and giving it to his disciples said,

    "Take and eat; this is my body."

    Then he took a cup, gave thanks, and gave it to them, saying,

    "Drink from it, all of you, for this is my blood of the covenant, which will be shed on behalf of many for the forgiveness of sins."



    (Mt 26:26-28; cf. Mk 14:22-24, Lk 22:17-20, 1 Cor 11:23-25)

    [​IMG]


     
    Last edited: Jan 16, 2017
  4. josephite

    josephite Powers

    Hi Muzhik,
    I listened to the video below,' a talk about the Catholic family given by Father Hardon in 1992', and one of the things that struck me was the extrodinary decline in Catholic dioceses worldwide. Apparently there were 2300 Catholic diocese and and he said 1900 had already disappeared!

    I took that to mean there must have been 4200 Catholic diocese worldwide, which was reduced to just 2300 (back in 1992), that was an extrodinary fall in numbers!

    It is edifying to hear that since 1992, there has been a growth in the numbers of dioceses worldwide.:)

     
    Last edited: Jan 16, 2017
  5. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    https://abyssum.org/2017/01/16/what...-sin-is-private-manifest-grave-sin-is-public/

    WHAT A DIFFERENCE ONE LITTLE WORD MAKES: “GRAVE SIN” IS PRIVATE, “MANIFEST GRAVE SIN” IS PUBLIC !!!
    Posted on January 16, 2017by abyssum
    [​IMG]
    VATICAN CITY, VATICAN – MARCH 13: Newly elected Pope Francis I appears on the central balcony of St Peter’s Basilica on March 13, 2013 in Vatican City, Vatican. Argentinian Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio was elected as the 266th Pontiff and will lead the world’s 1.2 billion Catholics. (Photo by Peter Macdiarmid/Getty Images)

    [ EMPHASIS AND {COMMENTARY} IN RED TYPE BY ABYSSUM ]
    Discussing law with people who don’t know what it actually says
    January 16, 2017
    Austen Ivereigh, in a Crux essay that adds little of substance to what has been said over and over again in regard to Amoris laetitia, fatally misquotes the central canon at issue in the Amoris debate. His misrepresentation of the law illustrates better than anything I could say here about why the Amoris debate is becoming, to use Ivereigh’s term, so infuriating for defenders of ecclesiastical tradition. The ‘pro-Amoris’ wing simply does not know, or care, what the law in question actually says.

    Ivereigh writes:

    “Amoris never questions either Canon 915, which demands that Communion be withheld from those who “obstinately persevere in grave sin,” nor the following canon, that people conscious of grave sin should not present themselves to receive Communion… But while Amoris is very clear about not wanting to create new norms or laws, it is also very clear about fostering a new attitude.”

    First Amoris never “questions” Canon 915 because it never mentionsCanon 915!, but much more importantly—and crucially for his essay—Ivereigh misquotes the text of Canon 915 in regard to the central issue here. Canon 915 does NOT say that holy Communion must be withheld from those who “obstinately persevere in grave sin”, it says that holy Communion must be withheld from those who “obstinately persevere in manifest grave sin”.

    The difference, as has been explained copiously, is night and day.

    Canon 915, controlling a minister’s decision to give holy Communion to a would-be communicant, is not, not, not, about reading communicants’ personal consciences (as if ministers could do that anyway), it is about assessing a would-be communicants’ public behavior (such as their having entered civil marriage subsequent to divorce).Thus, virtually all of the Amoris discussions about individual assessments of conscience or, as the Maltese bishops put it, about “being at peace with God” (points that might figure in the application of Canon 916), is irrelevant to the operation of Canon 915, the modern canon resting on ancient roots that prevents ministers from giving holy Communion to Catholics in these circumstances. But it’s impossible to discuss the implications of the legal qualifier “manifest” in Canon 915 if public figures such as Invereigh don’t even admit the word is there.

    Misrepresenting the plain text of canon law on the central point at issue in the Amoris debate is not, I suggest, how should one go “about fostering a new attitude” toward law.
     
    Pray4peace likes this.
  6. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://www.lmschairman.org/2017/01/malta-sinks.html?m=1

    Malta sinks
    'Weep not for me, but for yourselves
    and for your children.'
    In World War II, Malta was described as the 'unsinkable aircraft carrier'. Well, it has sunk now. The Bishops of Malta (both of them) have stated that anyone in an irregular union who feels 'at peace with God' should not be excluded from Holy Communion or from Sacramental Absolution: at least, that's what they seem to say. Readers can judge for themselves.

    If, as a result of the process of discernment, undertaken with “humility, discretion and love for the Church and her teaching, in a sincere search for God’s will and a desire to make a more perfect response to it” (AL 300), a separated or divorced person who is living in a new relationship manages, with an informed and enlightened conscience, to acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God, he or she cannot be precluded from participating in the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist (see AL, notes 336 and 351).

    Again:
    there are complex situations where the choice of living “as brothers and sisters” becomes humanly impossible and give rise to greater harm (see AL, note 329).
    I wonder what would happen of a priest decided that an adulterer had not undertaken a process of discernment with the requisite humility? If he'd had humility, but not 'love for the Church'? Or maybe that his 'search for God's will' was not, as required, 'sincere'? Would Archbishop Scicluna congratulate such a priest for his pastoral sensitivity?

    [​IMG]But to cheer us up, there is a very interesting and helpful interview with Cardinal Caffara to read, and canonist Edward Peters brilliantly summarises the fundamental confusions and incoherences of the Maltese statement. The Catholic Herald report on the Maltese document, by Dan Hitchens, says everything I would want it to say.

    This crisis is truly separating the men from the boys in the Church. We can either side with Christ, and his difficult, demanding, but also beautiful words on marriage and divorce, or side with the Pharisees and their modern-day successors, who search out specious casuistical exceptions to the rule until the rule is no more: who nullify God's will by the traditions of men.

    Once you start noticing how people sometimes accuse their opponents of the specific faults which they fear they have themselves, you start seeing it everywhere...
     
    HeavenlyHosts likes this.
  7. padraig

    padraig Powers


    ahh only two Bishops. That's a relief. They would not be Bishops too long if I had anything to do with it. They would not be in the Church either.
     
    HeavenlyHosts likes this.
  8. padraig

    padraig Powers

    The big question of course being why were these two Bishops not Excommunicated and publicly Excommunicated, Bell, Book and Candle as soon as they opened their big mouths? Why is there no word of them being kicked out? Why are they still in office?

    What does this mean?

     
  9. Astrolabe

    Astrolabe New Member

    Thank you - that is very true, and I never thought of it that way. I'm glad I asked, because sometimes it's only when we ask these things that we get a better understanding.

    I appreciate your help :)
     
  10. Light

    Light Guest

    Padr
    Padraig

    To me it means, that such appalling statements (Argentinian hierarchy understanding, German Bishops take on the AL implementation, San Diego Bishop and others) have months of life without any negative response from Vatican; in fact tacit support is given since Vatican paper republished. Actions speak louder than words, but inaction speaks louder in this case, and makes it is self-evident we are headed in very dangerous path.

    The whole story is not yet written, but we can be assured, we cannot loose! We will forever cling to the "Faith of our Fathers".

    God Bless
     
  11. Clare A

    Clare A Powers

    Light, you are right. Someone here (sorry but I forget who it was) quoted Malachi Martin who said we should not look at what people say but what they do. I think this is what is causing such confusion, because Pope Francis says some very beautiful things, but then he does or allows alarming things, such as the promotion of Card. Kasper and the sidelining of Cards. Pell, Burke and Sarah, to say nothing of the sacking without explanation of the three theologians at the CDF.

    According to Fr Malachi it is in the actions that we see the true intent.
     
  12. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://unamsanctamcatholicam.blogspot.com/2017/01/benefit-of-doubt-presumes-doubt.html

    Benefit of the Doubt Presumes Doubt

    A lot has been going on in the Church in the past few weeks. Most of it has happened too fast for me to event digest let alone have any sort of cogent commentary on - and that's okay, because I don't feel any need to keep up with it all. As God lives, I rejoice that I don't. I recently posted an article on the sister site on the history of Eucharistic Adoration from the apostolic age to the year 1264 and that was much more edifying.

    The other day I waded onto social media to see what some of the chatter-boxes were saying about a lot of these developments. It was very disappointing. I have never seen so many otherwise faithful and intelligent people sticking their heads in the sand about the present pontificate. "Maybe he is being misreported" they say. Ugh...I've been hearing that line since the days of John Paul II and I am so sick of it. It's been repeated ad nauseam for three pontificates. If the popes are so constantly being misquoted, you would think that once - just one time in three pontificates - at least one of those popes who are always being "misquoted" would have stepped up and corrected the misquotation.

    "Hrum hrum...I would check the Vatican website. If it's not in an official publication of the Vatican, I wouldn't believe it", says the guy who didn't believe John Paul II said "May St. John the Baptist protect Islam!"...until I showed it to him on the Vatican website.

    Derp.

    "Well, we always have to give people the benefit of the doubt." You know what, this is certainly true, and a very solid piece of Christian advice. We must always first seek to give someone the benefit of the doubt and interpret their words in the most charitable way possible. But the other day I heard an interesting corollary of this: instead of "always give people the benefit of the doubt", a priest said, "I can always find a benefit of the doubt." The difference is subtle but important. "Always give people the benefit of the doubt" means that before assuming the worst, we assume the best. Only if the best proves incorrect do we then assume the worst.

    But saying "always give the benefit of the doubt" also implies that sometimes the benefit of the doubt is the wrong assessment of what is happening. Any rational judgment of a situation requires that we reserve the right to simply see what is going on - to acknowledge our first impression, while charitable, might be wrong. To say "I can always find a benefit of the doubt" seems to say "No matter what the truth of the situation is, I can always find some way to spin this to avoid confronting the truth." It is the difference between saying I will always offer a benefit of the doubt and "I know I can find a beneficial way to interpret this" - you see?

    I admire people who seek for the truth and understand offering benefits to facts that may seem unflattering. I despise it when people have already determined they have found their narrative when it runs counter to everything else that we know. I will always extend our pontiff or any other clergyman the benefit of the doubt - but hell, sometime the facts are so manifest there is no more doubt. If some local politician says "African Americans commit a disproportionate amount of crime in our city," that comment could be interpreted in a racist manner (blacks commit more crime because they are inherently disposed to violence), or it could be interpreted in a non-racist manner (conditions of poverty and lost opportunity disproportionately affect black neighborhoods and result in a cycle of crime); in such a scenario, I would give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he meant it in the latter sense. I can do this precisely because there is a doubt about what he means.

    But sometimes there isn't a doubt. If the same politician (sorry to be crude) were to say, "Damn, I seriously hate those niggers"..well, there would really be no "doubt" left to give him the benefit of. In such a case, one must simply accept the truth, unpleasant though it is. The guy is racist. That's all there is to it.

    However, suppose one of our brightsiders approaches the problem with characteristic head-in-the-sand logic. "Perhaps when he said 'niggers' he wasn't referring to black people", or, "Well, yeah, he says he hates 'niggers', but if you ignore that one statement and look at all the other non-racist statements he made, you'll see he's not really racist at all", or "Maybe all those media outlets misquoted him when he said he hates niggers, even though neither he nor his office have offered any clarification suggesting otherwise" or "Well, reality is very complex and I am sure there was much, much more to the story than just saying he 'hates niggers' and since I don't know every single last fact I can't possibly make any judgement."

    In other words, to give the "benefit of the doubt" in the face of plain evidence to the contrary becomes no longer a benefit accorded to a doubt, but rather wishful thinking of the most fantastical sort.

    Please, I am not referring to any one issue or statement or action of the pope or anyone else. I just talking about...the same stupid ho-hum-fingers-in-the-ears-nothing-to-see-here-twelve-things-to-know-and-share-nobody-can-know-all-the-facts-nothing-new-who-made-you-judge? sort or nonsense.


    Ugh. I am so sick of it.
     
  13. That's terribly wrong Latin.
     
    BrianK likes this.
  14. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    Its historical use was never intended to be more ;-)
     
    any name you wish likes this.
  15. BrianK

    BrianK Guest

    http://voiceofthefamily.com/paul-eh...mass-sterilisation-given-platform-by-vatican/

    Paul Ehrlich – advocate of forced abortion and mass sterilisation given platform by Vatican
    January 18, 2017
    [​IMG]
    Pope Francis, Margaret Archer, Archbishop Sorondo
    One of the world’s leading advocates of reducing human population by abortion and contraception is to address a Vatican conference. Paul Ehrlich, author of the discredited book, The Population Bomb, will be speaking at the Vatican event, entitled “Biological Extinction”, which will be held from 27 February to 1 March, despite having expressed support for forced abortion and mass sterilisation.

    The event will be jointly hosted by the Pontifical Academy of Science and the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences. Both of these Vatican agencies have, since the election of Pope Francis, hosted some of the world’s leading population control advocates. Pope Francis has expressed himself “gratified” by the Sustainable Development Goals, which seek universal access to “sexual and reproductive health” by 2030. These terms are used to promote abortion and contraception worldwide.

    Paul Ehrlich is an outspoken advocate of killing children in the womb. In a 2011 interview he suggested that it would be better for many girls to killed in the womb, by sex-selective abortion, than be born. In the same interview he supported the principles behind compulsory mass sterilisation and spoke positively about government control over human fertility. In his 1977 work Ecoscience he called for “compulsory population-control laws, even including laws requiring compulsory abortion.” More recently he has said:

    “The idea that every woman should have as many babies as she wants is to me exactly the same kind of idea as everybody ought to be permitted to throw as much of their garbage into their neighbour’s backyard as they want.”

    Not surprisingly, given his expressions of support for forced abortion and mass sterilisation, Paul Ehrlich has also expressed anti-Catholic views. In a 2014 book, Hope on Earth: A Conversation, he has said that “the most unethical thing going on now” in religion is the Catholic Church’s “opposition to the use of contraception” of which the “main source” is “the Vatican and its bishops.” Furthermore he asserted that “the pope and many of the bishops are one of the truly evil, regressive forces on the planet”.

    Ehrlich is best known for his discredited 1968 work The Population Bomb, in which he falsely predicted that hundreds of millions of people would starve to death in the 1970s, including 65 million Americans. He even asserted that it was possible that “England will not exist in the year 2000.” In reality, the population of the earth has doubled since 1968 without any of the catastrophic consequences predicted by Ehrlich occurring.

    The PASS, under the presidency of Dr Margaret Archer, has consistently provided a platform for leading figures of the population control movement including Dr Jeffrey Sachs, the special adviser to outgoing UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon. Sachs, who considers killing unborn children to be a “cost-effective” way of reducing fertility rates, has participated in at least twelve events at the Vatican during the current pontificate. A pro-life activist, who questioned Dr Archer’s collaboration with Sachs, was told: “I am appointed by the Pope and responsible directly to him. I’m afraid that leaves you and your cohort out in the cold.”

    Pope Francis has frequently spoken out against abortion but his continued support for the Sustainable Development Goals, and his failure to prevent Dr Archer using her position to provide platforms for those, such as Paul Ehrlich, who favour the killing of unborn children, make his words sound increasingly hollow.
     
  16. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    Also remember the praise lavished by PF on Emma Bonino - "a forgotten great" :sick:
     
    BrianK likes this.
  17. Niklas

    Niklas Member

    TLIG Feb 1, 1988
    "I have so many times asked for the consecration of My daughter, Russia; I have implored her consecration;"
     
    earthtoangels likes this.
  18. padraig

    padraig Powers

  19. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    http://www.onepeterfive.com/surprising-german-editorial-de-facto-schism-church/

    A Surprising German Editorial: A De Facto Schism in the Church
    [​IMG] Maike Hickson January 18, 2017
    Out of Germany there now come to us some newly unexpected and surprisingly strong words. For, the candid source is that same national Catholic newspaper,Die Tagespost, and that same Rome Correspondent – Guido Horst himself – whom we had just a few days ago politely criticized for his claim that the debate about Amoris Laetitia is – and should be – now over and closed.

    To do justice to this new important 16 January editorial statement from Germany, I shall therefore present a translation in full of Horst’s somewhat short but incisive statement concerning the current situation in the Church:

    Editorial: A De Facto Schism

    by Guido Horst

    Whoever these days walks through the Vatican and speaks with individual clergymen about the broadening of the conflict concerning Amoris Laetitia meets with speechlessness; it is a speechlessness which also can – depending upon the intuition of the individual clergyman with regard to theological succinctness and the weight of doctrine – even broaden itself out into a complete bewilderment. With his own vote – as he presented it on Italian television – according to which certain ambiguities of the eighth chapter of the post-synodal document are “not a danger to the Faith” and thus a correction of the pope is impossible at this moment, Cardinal Gerhard Müller has likely made a quite consequential decision. There will not be any answer now coming from Francis to the questions, respectively as to the doubts of the four cardinals. Otherwise, the Prefect of the Congregation for the Faith would not have spoken so unambiguously. But the answers are coming now from other directions. The Church of Malta is a small local church at the periphery of Europe, but the Archbishop of Malta, Charles Scicluna is a respectable man who as a leading collaborator with the Congregation for the Faith had a decisive role at the time of the abuse scandals. When he – together with the bishop of Gozo – now instructs the pastors of his own small island state that every remarried divorcee may deal himself with the dear God as to whether he may go to Communion (see page 5 [of Die Tagespost]), then that means very clearly that each local church may now do as it pleases. The furrow grows deeper. Florence against Rome, Poland against Argentina, Malta against Milan. That is what one calls a de facto schism.

    The Vatican which once was able – for example, in the case of the German system of counseling pregnant women in need – and after a long struggle to implement a decision dedicated to the clarity of the witness – at the time for [the sanctity of human] life – is now not any more capable to ensure such clarity. The pope is silent concerning the letter of the [four] cardinals and thus indirectly refuses to give a clear statement according to which the controversial paragraphs of Amoris Laetitia must be read in light of the proclamation of the previous popes. That, too, is an answer. And the Prefect of the Congregation for the Faith declares that the debates concerning the requested papal clarification is now at an end. Rome is not any more a clarifying authority, but a quiet observer who silently keeps watch on how – and while – the unity of the Church’s pastoral care breaks into pieces.

    As so often happens, this takes place on the back of the “small people.” In this case, there are the many pastors who will have to explain to the faithful – and then also to those standing at a distance from the Church – what exactly has now changed. The morality, the Sacraments, the pastoral care? The good intention of the pope – namely that sinning and weak people do not excommunicate themselves any longer, but now recognize that there is also still a place in the Church for them – thus threatens to drown itself in the midst of the cluelessness of the pastors and with an increasingly venomous ongoing controversy between theologians and bishops. Cardinal Carlo Caffarra (see page 5 [of Die Tagespost]) is right when he says that this is especially a burden for the priests – a burden which they cannot bear. But, now they are left alone. [my emphasis]

    We wholeheartedly commend Guido Horst for such a loyal witness to, and such a courageous defense of, the truth.

    (cont'd below)
     
    BrianK likes this.
  20. SgCatholic

    SgCatholic Guest

    In a similar vein – and as an addition to Horst’s words – Carl Olson, the editor ofCatholic World Report, also criticizes Pope Francis for his causing so much moral confusion. Olson says in a 14 January article:

    The current papacy of sentimentality has produced confusion and conflict. As Cardinal Caffera states in a recent interview, “Only a blind man can deny that there is great confusion in the Church.” The clarity that Cardinal Müller speaks of so strongly is not just lacking, it seems to be absent altogether. There are directly competing interpretations of Amoris Laetitia: some by “conservative” prelates who refer to the perennial teachings of the Church and some are by progressive bishops who refer only to Amoris Laetitia and are published in the Vatican newspaper. The Pope’s Exhortation may not always be clear, but his intentions and goals are increasingly so. [my emphasis]

    In light of these forthright and stirring comments written by Guido Horst and Carl Olson, it might be noteworthy to make reference also to an article published today on the official website of the German bishops, Katholisch.de. The article is written by Björn Odendahl and rebukes the conservative Catholics for their perceived moral resistance toward Amoris Laetitia, saying quite assuredly that their words “are becoming more and more absurd.” He even sees “hatred” coming from that direction. (In one rather indirect quote, he even seems to refer to Guido Horst’s own above-translated article.) The importance of this polemical article, however, lies in its last paragraph:

    In one aspect, the conservatives are right: the words of the pope are not always clear enough. He should raise once more his voice and soon put an end to these goings-on which damage the Church. [my emphasis]

    While Odendahl – who himself not long ago had made a stir because of his demeaning remarks concerning the African Church’s opposition to any permissive laxening of the Church’s moral teaching – might now also wish that Pope Francis put an end to the irritant conservative resistance, we do actually agree with him on at least one essential aspect: It is up to the Vicar of Christ on earth once more to raise his authoritative voice and to clarify Amoris Laetitia. Here Odendahl even effectively agrees with the three bishops of Kazhakstan who have just made an eloquent public appeal for exactly that same intention.
     
    BrianK likes this.

Share This Page