j Free will is not a myth. Every human being is given free will. Misuse of it causes us to sin. God knew that Adam and Eve would sin before he created them, but He went ahead anyway. Adam and Eve ignored God's warning and chose by their own free will to listen to the serpent instead. Jesus knew that Judas would betray Him and could have stopped Judas but doing so would have interfered with Judas' free will. Judas could have changed his mind right up to the time he betrayed Jesus with a kiss. Judas could have repented but chose to kill himself instead. We don't know for sure whether Judas is in Hell but can make a good guess based on Jesus' words that it would be better he had never been born. Pontius Pilate had free will, declared that he believed Jesus to be innocent and could have set Him free but chose not to. God knows the final destination of everyone because God is outside time. He knows who will heed His word, pray for grace and co-operate with that grace and who won't but he will never go against our free will. God lets us choose good or evil. What you have described, Crewdog, is contrary to the Catholic faith. Here's a link to an article about Predestination, including the Catholic Dogma: https://www.catholic.com/encyclopedia/predestination
http://magister.blogautore.espresso...titia-malta’s-sailboat-joins-the-papal-fleet/ "Amoris Laetitia". Malta’s Sailboat Joins the Papal Fleet 14 gen «If, as a result of the process of discernment, undertaken with "humility, discretion and love for the Church and her teaching, in a sincere search for God’s will and a desire to make a more perfect response to it" (AL 300), a separated or divorced person who is living in a new relationship manages, with an informed and enlightened conscience, to acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God, he or she cannot be precluded from participating in the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist (see AL, notes 336 and 351).» In brief: yes to communion for the divorced and remarried who live more uxorio. This is the key point of the instructions that the bishops of Malta and Gozo, Charles Jude Scicluna and Mario Grech, gave to their priests on January 13, for the application of the controversial chapter VIII of "Amoris Laetitia": > Criteria for the Application of Chapter Eight of "Amoris Lætitia" So far not many bishops, whether alone or in groups, have given their priests similar instructions on the synodal exhortation. With conflicting viewpoints. For example, the ‘no’ to communion for the divorced and remarried who live more uxorio has been supported in the United States by Philadelphia archbishop Charles J. Chaput and in Italy by Cardinal Ennio Antonelli, called in by the archbishop of Florence, Giuseppe Betori, to educate the priests of his diocese. While the ‘yes’ has been backed by cardinal vicar of Rome Agostino Vallini and by the bishops of the region of Buenos Aires, in both cases with the personal approval of Pope Francis, in the United States by San Diego bishop Robert W. McElroy, and now, on the island of Malta, by bishops Scicluna and Grech. And both sides have supported their respective positions based on what they have found written in "Amoris Laetitia": glaring proof that the "dubia" raised publicly by four cardinals with the request that Pope Francis “bring clarity" are by no means castles in the air. So if the pope does not respond to the "dubia" it is because right from the start he wanted this plurality of interpretations and applications, all of them appealing to a composition of "Amoris Laetitia" that is deliberately ambiguous, and thus open to more than one interpretation. Now, which interpretation the pope prefers is absolutely certain. It is the one that admits communion for the divorced and remarried who live more uxorio. Which is exactly what one gets from a "naive" interpretation of the post-synodal exhortation, where this admission is not written anywhere "apertis verbis" but is made obvious by allusive means. It is no coincidence that the bishops of Malta, when they go so far as to write that the divorced and remarried who live more uxorio "cannot be precluded from participating in the sacraments of Reconciliation and the Eucharist" can find no suitable quote from "Amoris Laetitia" other than two cryptic footnotes, which on one occasion Francis even said he did not remember. But in fact, there are so many quotes from "Amoris Laetitia" in the instruction of the Maltese bishops that it leads one to think that theirs is actually a faithful “sine glossa” interpretation of the exhortation. * In the meantime, since Settimo Cielo last tallied the stances on the “dubia” among the cardinals and bishops, two more positions have been formulated. Support for the "dubia" has been expressed by South African cardinal Wilfrid Fox Napier, archbishop of Durban. While speaking out against it is Cardinal Lorenzo Baldisseri, secretary general of the synod of bishops, in an interview with "L'Osservatore Romano" on January 12: “Various responses have already been provided. And persons who are qualified by their roles and authority have made statements. [...] I do not think that anything else needs to be added, except to reiterate that all the responses that are required are already contained in the text of the apostolic exhortation itself.” (English translation by Matthew Sherry, Ballwin, Missouri, U.S.A.)
Who said anything about Free Will being a Myth ... except you, Dolours! I'm simply stating the obvious!! Jesus was sent "Down-Here" by The Father for The Mission of Saving Our Souls. That Mission had to end at Golgotha and the Empty Tomb! In order for that to happen certain big/bit players had to Play Their Parts. Is that True or False? ... Eh!!?? Ya Know, Gang! Most folks here have figured out that I have little patience, "These-Days" for religious know-it-alls 'cause if the future is what I think it is these types won't be worth a S*** in my foxhole ......... come to think of it! From what we read in the Scripture, Jesus didn't have much use in His "foxhole" for the Know-It-Alls of His Day ..... High Priests, Scribes & Pharisees! GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
Lack of patience doesn't excuse rudeness. Nobody here is claiming to "Know-it-All". I simply gave you the basics that every Catholic child learns. That God endows every human being with free will is basic Catholic teaching. That God created us to know, love and serve him here on earth and to live forever with him in Heaven after our death is also basic Catholic teaching, as is God being outside time and knowing from the very beginning where each of us will spend eternity, and that God sends us the grace to help us get to Heaven. There's a load of theology behind it that's way out of my sphere of understanding, so I provided a link that helps explain how the Church arrived at that dogmatic teaching. Here's how I came to the conclusion that you are suggesting that Free will is a myth: First, you tell us that the Passion of Jesus was a "Divine Play" where characters were "scripted to do their part". I still believe, Gang, that we are making things we can't quite understand and have limited knowledge of into distraction, disunity and diversion that is counterproductive in normal times and possibility dangerous These-Days! I believe The Three Year Ministry and Passion of Jesus was a Divine Play where characters were scripted to do their parts so that The Blood of The Cross, Resurrection and Salvation .... and founding of The Church could happen! I truly believe that it's as simple as that. That means Peter, Judas, Pilate, The High Priests and you name them all had to do their part/mission as directed. What if Pilate decided to unilaterally declare Jesus innocent ... or The High Priests or how about that Guy who had to show with the five loaves and fish ... or if there was plenty of wine at the Wedding ... it ALL had to happen as scripted for Our Good! Can it be that simple? I believe so!! I've said before that I wouldn't be surprised to meet Judas in Heaven or many of The Bad Guys. I think we are living in a Divine Play now and I'd suggest we tend to our "Parts" and worry less about the scripts of others! Then you tell us in your next post that "Free Will had to be suspended for the actors to properly do their parts in the 'Play'." Well! If my theory of Divine Play is correct and actors having to play out their assigned parts, then I can only assume that Free-Will had to be suspended for the actors to properly do their parts in the "Play". Does anyone here believe that "It Just Happened That Way"?? .... Without DIRECT INPUT from The Father? I don't consign ANYONE to Hell ... It ain't my job ... Thankfully! Then you develop it further by telling us that many of our "Good as Gold" beliefs could be revealed as myths in the next life: Well!! I'm guessing we will have to wait till the Next Life for this and a whole Host of Mysteries to be explained ....... Truths Revealed......... and many of our "Good as Gold" beliefs revealed to be myths! I'm sorry, CrewDog, for trying your patience, but I couldn't ignore the suggestion that the Catholic faith permits us to believe that God created some human beings for the sole purpose of sinning against Him. I agree with you that we will have to wait until the next life to fully understand God's omnipotence, but meanwhile we can trust in the Church's teaching. Free will is one of those "Good as Gold" beliefs.
Dolours, Thank you for your for your Know-It-All Mega-Reply but ... I asked a simple True or False Question!: "Jesus was sent "Down-Here" by The Father for The Mission of Saving Our Souls. That Mission had to end at Golgotha and the Empty Tomb! In order for that to happen certain big/bit players had to Play Their Parts. Is that True or False?" Kindly answer! True or False! ... and spare us all the .. I'm wounded by that nasty CrewDog histrionics! GOD SAVE ALL HERE!!
Can you at least try to be civil? I'm not at all wounded by your nastiness. Jesus was sent "down here" by the Father. The Mission ended at Gogotha and the empty tomb. All that is true. Whether they "had" to happen in that time and place is another matter. That's something you can discuss with God when you meet Him in Heaven. As to the whys and wherefores of Predestination, you can read the piece that I linked to. Here it is again: https://www.catholic.com/encyclopedia/predestination Divine Providence is also relevant to the topic, and you can read about that here: https://www.catholic.com/encyclopedia/Divine-Providence Now, when you've read all that, you can fill us all in on why the Church teaches what it does about free will. Let me know if you find something in there about free will being suspended and I promise not to accuse you of being a "Know-it-All".
For all you know, I could be a higher smellin' and lower down pilgrim than anyone. There's nothing civil about name-calling. We're all trying to make our way to Heaven. Most of us try to have some manners while we struggle along. I didn't say that God doesn't intervene, otherwise I would have to deny actual and sanctifying grace. Those pieces from the Catholic Encyclopaedia that I linked to are interesting and informative. I learned something from them, and thought that others reading the thread might also find them beneficial. I'm glad when other members quote or provide links to anything that will aid my understanding of the Faith because the one thing I'm absolutely sure of is that I don't "Know-it-All". You, on the other hand?????????? Goodnight to you, CrewDog, and may God bless you. I won't be responding to any more of your comments on the issue of free will because nobody benefits from trading insults.
Keep up the Good Work, Dolours. Simply explaining and defending the basics of the Faith never constitutes being a "Know-it-all." Preserving and defending Eternal Truth is, frankly, far more important than temporal preps or physically surviving. Illegitimi non carborundum.
Oh, I know you're not Padraig. The question is, given the timing and the headlines, was the message itself.
Thanks Brian, but I'm finished with this. Best to hold fast to the faith handed down to us and follow Julia's example of prayer and fasting because the same accusations of Know-it-All, Scribe, Pharisee, High Priest, etc. will be dusted off and recycled when the doctrine is "developed" to embrace every kind of sexual union under the sun. In fact, the way AL is being interpreted, no further development will be necessary until the blessing of homosexual unions is sanctioned....blessings that mimic the Sacrament of marriage but are called something else by smooth talking theologians as they spin yet another "beautiful document" to the great unwashed. Every time I see the statement "AL is a beautiful document" I'm reminded of the story of Samson and Delilah. I'll bet that Samson was still telling Delilah how beautiful she was as his hair was being chopped off. All our bishops are jetting to Rome this week. We haven't be told why but I'm sure it isn't to measure their carbon footprint. I suppose it's too much to hope that even one of them would support the dubia.
I heard a snippet of news as I was passing a radio at the weekend. All I heard was that all the Irish Bishops will be going to Rome "next week" which I presume is this week now and that no reason was given. Maybe they're going to plan the Pope's visit next year. I'm sure it would be all over the papers and international news if it were bishops worldwide.
Noted! I apologize for all the bruised toes amongst my MOG Friends! GOD SAVE ALL HERE!! PS: The Vatican may or may not have fallen but The Church of Jesus Christ is alive & well .... as usual!
The Irish bishops are going for their "ad limina" visits to the Pope. According to Canon Law, every bishop is required to make an in-person report on the state of his diocese to the Pope every 5 years. Given the growth in the number of dioceses worldwide and the fact that Francis suspended "ad limina" visits during the Year of Mercy, that "every 5 years" is more of a goal at this time than an actual fact. The Irish bishops are first this year, followed by Serbia and later on by Canada. Canadian bishops have not had an "ad limina" visit since 2006. Source: Back to bishops: Pope's 2017 calendar filled with 'ad limina' visits
I wish everyone were as humble as you Denis. I wish I were as humble as you. I wish I were as humble as you but pigs might fly. View attachment 5996
https://cruxnow.com/commentary/2017/01/15/ethicist-says-ghostwriters-role-amoris-troubling/ View attachment 5997