I feel like I am appearing live on some awful horror film when I view the Church at the moment. A little voice inside my head keeps saying, 'This cannot be happening, this is not real, this is not happening...' over and over and over. But it is happening. Horror of horrors . It is happening.
It occurred to me that when Jesus was at the Last Supper. He knew that Judas was about to commit the most serious sin in betraying the Son of God. To be honest we know Jesus said to Judas go now and do what you have to do. HMMMM I think we underestimate the seriousness of the sin of betrayal. But I don't want to get into a debate on that topic if you please. If Jesus knew Judas was about to commit what must have been a mortal sin; and Jesus still Personally offered Judas the Consecrated Bread and Wine. Should we be judging what the Church does, with such passion. When you think about it. If someone commits a crime in our societies, anyone who condoned or assisted in the crime is also held accountable. On that premise, we could be condemning Jesus for allowing Judas to partake of Jesus Body and Blood. I think we have a duty of care to take this into consideration when we get on our pulpits. Yes, we have a duty to uphold and share the Faith of our Fathers. We have a duty to examine our own conscience; but have we the right to examine everyone else's. Or should we be giving good example, and speaking the Truths when we are asked with charity and gentleness. Just another perspective.
If there was 'valid grounds' for the reversal of church teaching it would have been championed by Pope Francis and his followers. The "best" they could come up with is "personal conscience", but they failed to say that it has to be in the light of Christ and his constant Churches teachings, which brings them to full circle in their error. What they are dealing with is a false sense of compassion for those who failed in their first valid marriage and are stuck between a rock and a hard place as it pertains to Jesus teaching, "any man divorce his wife and marries another commits adultery". It has in large part been the fault of progressive bishops and pastors within the local dioceses and parishes that has brought us this dilemma via poor catechisis and marriage preparations and and now they are the same ones saying to use their conscience and receive the body and blood of Jesus if you "feel at peace". Pope Paul VI was a prophet in his teaching in Humane Vitae on the effects of the contraceptive world and hit has come home to roost.
I believed this prior to the first synod and was still hoping it was true during the second synod. It is apparent now, my optimism was wrong.
But Julia, did Jesus allow Judas to do this? Where in scripture does it say Judas was given the Body and blood by Jesus and consumed it?
How do you know that the Doctrine of Infallibility won't be invoked if Pope Francis can't silence the opposition to this change? I suspect that, apart from being unsure how much push-back he would face, he is reluctant to invoke Infallibility while he is promoting inter-Communion with Lutherans. Regarding the "Jesus gave Communion to Judas" argument, was Judas already in Mortal Sin before he actually betrayed Jesus? I was taught that planning to commit sin is not actually a mortal sin until we implement our plan. Judas still had time to change his mind after he left the room.
Also Jesus as far as I remember clearly singled Judas out as the traitor. As far as I recall what Jesus did was to dip a piece of bread in to the gravy and hand it to Judas. Not the blessed bread just the bread unblessed, dipped in the gravy.
Julia, I remember being taught about God's permissive will and God's active will. Jesus always knew what would happen with Judas, even before he began his public life. Up to the moment Judas accepted the Body and Blood at the Last Supper his free will was in operation. I remember reading (don't have time to look up) that Satan entered into Judas after he made that bad communion, and he went out to accomplish his mission. Jesus never willed Judas to betray him, nor was he an accomplice. But for whatever reason God loves and allows us free will, Jesus let Judas's choice stand. That DOES NOT MEAN that a priest today should allow (for example) a member of The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence to sashay up the aisle and receive communion while laughing and mocking the Mass. The Church has set up rules for receiving communion, which are honored in Heaven (whatsoever you bind on earth...)
Every time I see posts condemning the Pope, it gives me a chill down my spine. Where were all your voices when Catholic women wore the coil in contradiction to Church teaching. The coil did it's job by aborting any child conceived during sexual relations. There must have been millions of undocumented abortions in defiance of Church teaching. Would those of you who condemn the Pope jump on your family, friends or colleagues if you saw them being unfaithful to their husbands or wives behind backs. I never met anyone who did that, yet in order for these relationships to get off the ground there must have been a hell of a lot of betrayal. Unholy marriages don't just fall from the sky, they are formed right in front of our noses. What did we do to preserve the sanctity of those marriages. Where were all the voices of disapproval, and warning to those who got into these circumstances. We can do something now. Promise God, we repent for our failure to shout from the rooftops in the past. Not at the Pope, at those we know who are breaking the sixth Commandment now. Of course we still have to lower the pitch and speak with charity and kindness. But we should be forming a dam now to stop any more souls being swallowed up in that tsunami of souls heading for unholy wedlock. Just another perspective.
Padraig, they did not have gravy, they had bread and wine, and I am sure Judas was offered at the same time as the rest of the Apostles. Jesus said the prayer before they eat. I am certain of that.
We should be doing a far, far greater evil , I think if we did not condemn the Pope when he needed condemning.
John 13:26 Jesus answered, "It is the one to whom I will give this piece of bread when I have dipped it in the dish." Then, dipping the piece of bread, he gave it to Judas, the son of Simon Iscariot. The dish was the dish with Passover Lamb. He dipped it for the gravy. View attachment 5988
Oh Padraig. I will have to go and find the place in the Bible where it all happened at the Last Supper. It is quite an eye opener when you think of it. It does say the devil entered Judas when he left the room of the Last Supper, not before, if that is any consolation to you.
In some places they say the Eucharist should be dipped in the Chalice. In those days I don't think they had butter, so dipping in the wine would make it nicer to consume. Also to me it unites the Sacred Species. We must find out from some Jews whither they have gravy with their Passover Lamb. I am sure they still have this ceremony in rememberance of their rescue.
I am still convinced Judas ate with the Apostles at the Last Supper. We know the blessings were done before meals unlike nowadays when we all get stuck in without remembering grace before meals. It would be the height of unacceptable to leave the Passover before it was finished, like getting up before the Christmas dinner was eaten, and why would they write about bread and gravy in the Gospels. It is an account of the institution of the Blessed Eucharist.
My wife and I taught NFP for years at least in part to provide an alternative to abortifacient contraceptives. I served as the chairman of a national pro life group and have written numerous articles and essays on pro life issues, contraception, abortifacients and the morning after pill. None of that compares to our DUTY to oppose the sacrilegious Communions proposed by this pope. And that does NOT constitute "condemning" or "attacking" him, or being "schismatic." It's simply an integral element of defending the faith at this time in history.
Because an infallible teaching must be one that Jesus taught and the Church has always believed. Individual conscience can never be a source of infallibility unless it be guided by the unchanging teachings of Jesus and 2000 years of his Church, which clearly is not the case. Scroll up, as I gave the Churches definition of infallibility.
This debate is torture because I am on day six of a bread and tea fast for God to preserve us from trouble during the time of the US Presidential handover. My teeth are watering.
I can't to be honest because I need to ask Jesus to have Mercy on me for my own failures in His service. I can confirm my belief in the traditions we inherited from our fathers, and marriage and holy orders are not allowed to be ended this side of the grave. And I would stand in the snow to help anyone I came across if it would help them preserve their marriage or vocation in Holy Orders. I would (and have) caution someone I met who had broken their vows to abstain from Holy Communion also while they were in such circumstance. Besides. There are Cardinals on the job now thanks be to God. I believe this is in answer to prayers of poor old biddies like me who are helpless and powerless without those Cardinals. Who would listen to the likes of me, only God, as long as I keep silent on my feelings in this crisis. Or as they say 'ponder it all in my heart,' like mama.