Thanks for that well considered and expressed reply, earthtoangels As you probably know, according to Mari Loli The Warning will happen in an even year and will happen within the same calendar year as The Miracle. The earliest possible year for these to take place, therefore, is 2018. According to Charlie, The Rescue is to take place this year which is of course an odd year but the process of Charlie's Rescue may extend to the time of The Miracle. In that case the Rescue will encompass The Warning. It seems to me, however, that the Rescue is oddly out of place in the sequence of events that has been foretold. Why have a Rescue before we have the Rescue that is inherent in the Warning. The answer to that may lie in your final sentence - we know from Sr Lucia of Fatima that God wants all credit for the final triumph to be given to Mary. Perhaps this appearance of Mary will give heart to the Church Militant as the appearance of a leader on the front line rallying the troops gives heart to an army ready to engage the enemy. It could be said that we are to be stirred by the Rescue (Reveille), awakened by the Warning and converted in The Miracle. It still seems strange to me that the seers of Garabandal would not have been told something of this Rescue. Our only caution about apparitions given at Garabandal was that many false ones would act as a distraction from the truth. We shall see ......shortly. If the members on Charlie's site are correct, everything is about to change. If they are wrong we still have Garabandal and things will never be the same again.